Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Aleksei K Belousov's avatar

Everyone jumped to hate VITAMINS. I feel it is not fare. Did he use hyperbole to bring attention to the matter? Yes he did. Do vitamins at the proposed doses cause harm? No, they don't. Are they imprtantant for endogenous production of cathecholomins and immune system ( two most important systems which get desregulated in septic shock). They are.

He, in fact, almost single handedly dismantled sepsis one compain. Educated the whole generation of doctors about the role of thiamine and vitamin c in critical illness. Educated about the role of glycocalix. Educated about mitochondrial health.

But everyone, from a first year resident to blog attendings ( except Josh Farkas) hated on vitamins...

Here is two from the same edition :

DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000005263

DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000005262

Yes, no mortality improvement. But if I can get anything out of vit c, I will take it. As I write daily progress notes, I do celebrate weaning from pressors. It appears that vit c can accelerate it. So maybe we can be more inquisitive and make mental adjustments to what effects are we are asking from simple vitamins?

Expand full comment
Aleksei K Belousov's avatar

Thank you for your reply and for what you do. I grew up as doctor on your teachings and posts from Farkas, Spiegel and Kenny.

Thank you for continuous engagement and life learning.

And thank you for taking my point as a tribute to a great master who was there before us. And maybe who can see a little bit further than us.

"The truth will always win".

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?